Work

The Strange, True Story of John Williams and Charles Pennock

Audubon Magazine

In the early 1900s it wasn’t unusual for men to suddenly go missing. Among them were two accomplished bird experts whose lives turned out to be surprisingly intertwined. Illustrated by Andrei Cojocaru


A Case for Solomon: Bobby Dunbar and the Kidnapping that Haunted a Nation

Free Press (Simon & Schuster)  ⁃  Buy on Amazon

In 1912, a young boy went missing in a swamp. Eight months later, he was found – but two mothers claimed him. The struggle over his identity altered fates and splintered families, and mystery endured for a century.


The Ghost of Bobby Dunbar

This American Life

Margaret Dunbar Cutright grew up with the tale of her grandfather’s kidnapping. When she dug deeper, the legend gave way to mystery, generations of festering pain, and a calling to find truth.


Shift

Watch the Film on Vimeo

Independent Television Service

A miserably married waitress chats up a charming telemarketer. Their romance brings her to life, but he has a secret.


Other Work

Biography

Tal McThenia is the co-author of A Case for Solomon: Bobby Dunbar and the Kidnapping That Haunted a Nation (with Margaret Dunbar Cutright; Simon & Schuster), an award-winning work of historical nonfiction about a notorious case of kidnapping and contested identity that divided the American South in the early twentieth century. The book was based on The Ghost of Bobby Dunbar, Tal’s one-hour documentary for the public radio series This American Life.

Most recently, Tal collaborated with legendary actor Dick Van Dyke to write 100 Rules for Living to 100: An Optimist’s Guide to a Happy Life (Grand Central Publishing) and with acclaimed interior designer Young Huh on her debut book A Mood, A Thought, A Feeling (Rizzoli). He has ghostwritten several other books across multiple genres.

His writing has appeared in VanityFair.com, Audubon Magazine, American Express Departures, Bloomberg Businessweek, Popula, and Atlas Obscura, among other venues. His work as a screenwriter includes Shift, a PBS drama; science mysteries for Mosa Mack Science; and the Nick Jr. series Butterbean’s Café.

Tal grew up in Rockbridge County, Virginia. He lives in New York City and upstate New York with his boyfriend, the writer Brett Berk.

Portrait of Tal McThenia in blue shirt

Photo by Stefanie Spina

Contact

Literary Agent: Zoë Pagnamenta, Calligraph

Please use this form to send inquiries to Tal. For your privacy, note that the information you enter here is not stored on third-party servers.

* Required so Tal can respond. A phone number is optional.


© 2025 Tal McThenia. All rights reserved
Background pic: South River Dam & Lock on the Maury River in Lexington, Virginia (via LOC’s Public Domain Archive)
Site built Nov-2025 by Kathy Cannon from HydeJack (free version) hosted on GitHub Pages

Powered by Hydejack v9.2.1